The 137th Preakness: Pretenders and Contenders

Kentucky Derby winner I'll Have Another looks for a win in the second leg of the elusive pursuit of the Triple Crown at the 2012 Preakness

The 137th Preakness: Pretenders and Contenders


Less than a week before the 137th Preakness it appeared there would be a full field for the fourth time during the past two decades – 14 horses going 1 3/16 miles at Pimlico.

But, alas, then sixth place Derby finisher Liaison and ninth place runner Hansen bowed out. So did newcomers Hierro, Brimstone Island and Paynter. That leaves a field of 11.

Twice the favorites in the second leg of the Triple Crown bounced back from defeats in the Kentucky Derby. Back in 1992, Pine Bluff, who finished off the board in the Derby, won the Preakness by three-quarters of a length.

In ’05 Afleet Alex captured the Preakness by 4 ¾ lengths after finishing third at Churchill Downs to longshot Giacomo. Ironically, Giacomo finished third at Pimlico.

Last year favored Animal Kingdom, the Derby winner, finished second to Preakness longshot Shackleford, who ran fourth in Louisville.

This year Bodemeister, favored at Louisville but second to longshot I’Il Have Another, has a good chance of redeeming himself.

The number of Derby horses in the Preakness has averaged about five the past 25 years. That’s the number likely to go Saturday in the probable field of 11.

So let’s start with the Pretenders:

First, I’m eliminating runners with only a single victory in their career: Cozzetti, a maiden winner last year; Optimizer, who hasn’t scored since his racing debut last August; and Teeth of the Dog, victorious only last February.

I’m also discounting slower horses: Guyana Star Dweej, Pretension and Zetterholm. I’m also disregarding Tiger Walk because of his lackluster form: fourth in his last pair.

Creative Cause made an eight wide run out of the Churchill Downs far turn to gain third in the stretch, but ended up fifth and hasn’t looked good in his last two chasing I’ll Have Another.

Now the Contenders:

Daddy Nose Best endured a horrible trip in the Derby right from the start after been forced in and steadied. Then the Sunland Derby winner made a good run to mid-stretch where he was bumped. A better trip should improve his 10th place finish and could put him in the money.

Went the Day Well was traveling best of all in the Derby, making up more than eight lengths in the stretch to finish fourth. A good run will mean hitting the board and maybe even result in a victory.

Bodemeister, with the lack of speed horses, most likely will go to the front. If he sets a sensible pace, he could go all the way.

I’ll Have Another has proved to be a real gamer in his last two triumphs. Both times he looked rivals in the eye and disposed of them. He should do it again.

4 Responses to “The 137th Preakness: Pretenders and Contenders”

  1. dave says:

    I think we can agree only 5 have a shot. I’m not sue I like why you threw CC out of the mix. Wildcard of the bunch.

  2. JIM BRESLIN says:

    How do you toss Roman’s horse? He has been very hot, decent jock, and picking spotw well finally. I had Dullahan in the Derby, and almost got it. Just curious-I get the lack of running, but we all know these 3 races are the most difficult to handicap. Thanks, Jim Breslin

  3. dave says:

    Is this Mountie Jim Breslin?

  4. TJK says:

    very nice post tjk

Leave a Comment